31Aug2011

The dreaded double "rr"

Today is the day I have been dreading for weeks.

My children are learning to read and write by working through every letter of the alphabet. When a new letter is introduced they listen to a small story that features an abundance of the the new letter. Such as,
"La llama llorona esta llorando porque se perdió su llave."
(The crying llama is crying because she lost her key.) 
Clearly that lesson is about the "ll".

I knew this day would come, I was simply waiting for the humiliation. One of the things I find most fascinating about  languages, is the difficulties non-native speakers have when trying to pronounce difficult native sounds.

For example,
1. "th" in English is incredibly difficult for Spanish speakers because there is no such sound in Spanish
2. The German umlaut (ü) is one of the impassable barriers between my German and the German I would like to have. I once told a receptionist that I need to "push my paper" because I can't correctly pronounce the difference between "drücken" (to push) and "drucken" (to print).
3. Then there is the horrible rolling of the "r". This hinders me from distinguishing between words like "dog" & "but" and "car" & "expensive"

Today my kids learned the "rr". Last week they learned about "rr"'s weak Superhero friend, the single "r". This weak "r" is scared by vowels so he makes a very quiet sound. But strong "rr" isn't afraid and makes a loud rolling sound.

The Spanish teacher left the room for a while so I had to help the students and needed to tell them words like "cart" and "vineyard," all with the "rr". I took to simply writing them down because I can't properly pronounce them and felt like I was hindering their understanding of the differences between the sounds.

When the teacher came back, I sheepishly told her that I can't roll my "r"s and using hand drawn illustrations, showed me how I can properly train my tongue to make the sound. She finished her explanation by saying, "You simply need to train the tongue. Since there are very few strong sounds in English your mouth is weak."

Hmph. At least I've still got "th".

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Allison S.'s avatar

Allison S. · 706 weeks ago

The German "r" is so much more difficult! rolling the "r" in the back of your mouth=impossible.
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
Allison, you are so right! For now I have abandoning most of my German grammar and pronunciation and replaced it with Spanish. But one day I will tackle those umlauts and "r"s.
I can help! (a little? maybe?)
Tell your kids they need to stick out their tongues to make the th sound. You can have them really exaggerate it and stick their tongues way out. But if they don't "saca la lengua" they won't be able to make a "th".

When I was in chorus, we sang in a variety of languages - learning to sing in Latin helped me a lot with Spanish pronunciation, but I still have a tendency to insert dipthongs where they shouldn't be (Tayamo instead of Te Amo), Anyway, she told us to make the umlaut sound by shaping the mouth like you're smiling and sucking through a straw - then say the long E sound. I don't know if it actually works, but I still do it!
My recent post Weekly Menu Plan – Sept 18-24
Kelly, if you could only see me right now, sitting in front of my computer screen attempt to make all these foreign sounds with the tips you gave me! That's great advice for the "th" and I am sure the kids will giggle at the sight of everyone sticking out their tongues. As for the umlaut, it sounds pretty good to me, though I don't claim to be a German expert. But hey, at least I am trying, right?

Post a new comment

Comments by